We stayed in an underground room with very small windows, and we could hear almost everything happening above us. However, that was not the main problem. Without what happened afterward, this honestly would have been a 5-star review.
When traveling, we normally try to avoid bringing race, ethnicity, religion, or politics into places where they do not belong. But on the same day we visited the Holocaust Museum in Amsterdam, we were shocked to see books and political material displayed in the dorm that, in our view, contained historically misleading claims, racial hatred, and rhetoric supporting violence against Jews.
The atmosphere affected us personally. My friend became genuinely afraid to speak his own language in the common areas and uncomfortable even leaving the room. Nobody traveling in Amsterdam should feel that they need to hide their language or identity inside the place where they are staying.
To be completely clear, our problem is not that members of the staff were Muslim, Arab, Palestinian, Israeli, or pro-Palestinian. Everyone is entitled to their identity and political opinions. Our problem was the material being openly displayed and the atmosphere it created for Jewish and Israeli guests.
If a business chooses to take a political side and display highly provocative political material, it cannot then be surprised when guests who are targeted or offended by that material object to it. Freedom to express a political position does not mean freedom from criticism for the environment that position creates.
Had cancellation been possible when we saw the books and understood the atmosphere, we would have cancelled our stay immediately and left. We did not want our money supporting a business that, in our view, allowed this kind of material to be displayed.
Amsterdam, of all cities, should understand why historical truth matters. European history demonstrates what can happen when propaganda, invented or distorted history, collective blame, and the dehumanization of an entire population become normalized. Those mechanisms were central to the rise of Nazism and ultimately contributed to catastrophic violence against Jews and many others.
That history should make us especially careful today. I strongly disagree with narratives about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict that erase or reinvent history, justify violence, or treat an entire nationality or religion as collectively guilty. Whatever someone's position on Israel or Palestine, historical claims should be examined critically rather than hatred being presented as education.
If people do not know Amsterdam's history, make it accessible to them in Arabic and other languages and encourage them to visit the monuments and museums throughout the city. Education and factual historical discussion are constructive; racial hatred and calls for violence are not.
I sincerely hope this was the decision of individual workers rather than the owners or management. If management knowingly permits material advocating racial or religious hatred or violence, I believe the booking platform should investigate it seriously. If the material violates the platform's anti-discrimination or safety policies, the property should be removed rather than continuing to receive bookings through the platform.
It is unfortunate because without this issue, our experience would have deserved five stars. The underground room, small windows, and noise from above were things we could accept. Feeling that my friend was afraid to speak his language or leave the room was not.