Island Magic Beach Resort

Great location. We swam right from their dock (saw eagle ray, sting ray, tarpoons) and used the pool every day. The swings, lounges, and tables in the back on the beach were really nice. The office staff and restaurant staff were super nice. The air conditioner was leaking water into the room and staff fixed it as soon as we notified them. My only complaint is when the room was cleaned staff moved our stuff off the table and organized everything. My ring was brushed off the nightstand and I found it under the bed. Staff should not move anything.

We had an amazing experience! The hotel was comfortable, clean, and perfectly located. The restaurant exceeded our expectations—the food was absolutely delicious, and every meal was fresh and beautifully prepared. What truly stood out was the excellent service; the staff was friendly, attentive, and made us feel welcome throughout our stay. We highly recommend this place to anyone visiting Caye Caulker. We can’t wait to return!

This property really turned out to be a gem. Our room was right outside the pool which is tucked down below behind the restaurant. Even on the most windy days we could get in the pool comfortably. Pool bar is a plus, those gals were very sweet. The AC in the room blows like a champ and was so comfy. Wholly housekeeping, they barely offer that in the US anymore so, it was so refreshing each day and filling our water pitcher was the best!! Food at the restaurant was good too. Def will be back, thanks Magic island.

There are some barking dogs next door in the morning, but not too bad. If you are on the upper floors there is no elevator. Restaurant/bar is good, pool is much smaller than the picture. Very close to the boat ferry landing.

The perfect place to stay on Caye Caulker! The most accommodating staff of our 12-day trip.

The staff at Island Magic Resort are absolutely phenomenal! The food is great, the drinks are great, the location is great, the rooms are clean with hot water, AC, and a turbo ceiling fan (at least in my room- which was amazing!). Spent many enjoyable moments in the swings and on the pier at Island Magic Resort! Absolutely wonderful! I was super sad to leave (currently sitting at the airport).

The room was very small and the bathroom was not very private. Walls did not go to the ceiling, I assume for ventilation. Restaurant was great and staff very friendly. Great location near ferry on the water.

The staff was wonderful and helpful! The room was spacious, clean and the Best coffee set up I’ve ever seen! I wasn’t there for the pool, so no comment on it. Don’t expect massive pools on this small island, but it did have a swim up bar. The bar and restaurant were excellent as well, with fantastic staff. I would book again with Island Magic Hotel💜

Coffee and water were provided. My roof did not face the beach but it was tidy and quite.