Hampton Bays Hotel on Main ★★

"Excellent"

Canoe Place Inn & Cottages ★★★★

"This historic hotel is absolutely beautiful, and the rooms are spectacular. Every detail has been thoughtfully considered. I loved that there were phone chargers on both sides of the bed—a small touch that made a big difference. I’m always a tough critic when it comes to hotel showers, and this one was outstanding! The plush towels, luxurious linens, incredibly comfortable bed, beautiful décor, thoughtfully curated books, and spotless room all exceeded my expectations. What truly made the stay special, however, was the warmth and kindness of the staff. Their hospitality was genuine and made us feel so welcome. Having just returned from a three-week trip through Europe, where we stayed in several exceptional five-star hotels, my expectations were very high. This hotel not only met them—it surpassed them. It is now at the very top of my list of favorite places to stay in the Hamptons. I can’t wait to come back."

Hamptons Vacation Inn ★★★

Bayview Resort ★★★

Ocean View Terrace ★★

"Enjoyed our 1 night stay and will be back next time we come for a visit to the area. Updated rooms were comfortable. Staff was very friendly and hospitable. Kids thoroughly enjoyed the pool which had a nice view of the bay. Complimentary breakfast was just was we needed before we got back on the road. All around exceeded expectations."

The Hampton Maid ★★

Hamptons Bay Home on Shinnecock Bay w/ Yard! ★★★

The Penny Lane ★★

"We came back for a nostalgia trip 40 years later. Lots of changes of course, great for the most part but the devil is in the details. There is no human contact when you get there, while you’re there, and when you leave, which to lots is a plus, but on the other hand when something goes wrong …it’s a process. So there’s new siding, new porches, new paint jobs, lawn chairs, lawn games etc but the rooms still have in wall/window air conditioners—ours was sooooo noisy we sacrificed the last night and opened the windows (the sills were filthy, prob never opened) and sweated it out bc we thought we had a better chance to sleep than the racket the funky AC gave us. The Bedding had a “blanket” that was folded in fashion to go across the bed mid way as is the style now except that it was so threadbare and frayed it was kinda gross. In any event for the money IDK, the pool was closed, the room was sub par —not even a mat when you walked in from the rain., the one shelf in the bathroom was in disrepair, slanted down so my stuff fell off it and half of it broke. The location is good, and like I said, we had a special nostalgic interest in returning, but this will be the last time I think."

Bay Watch Hotel and Marina ★★★