We stayed this past weekend (5/7 to 5/10) My wife and I ave been to Key West many times and I can't tell you how much we enjoyed our stay at the Artist House. Sophie and Lisa were our hosts and both were very pleasant and bent over backwards to take care of any requests. Now this is an old charming house and a bed and breakfast, not a hotel. I felt like I was reliving my youth at my grandparents house in the Irish Channel part of New Orleans. So if you want fancy modern, this might not be the place for you. But my wife and I absolutely loved it, we stayed in the Eugene Suite.
To compare it to our last stay at the Duval house, it just felt different, more homey I guess. I liked that the breakfast was different every morning which was cool. What was also really great was that they have a free Happy Hour (Beer, wine and soft drinks)
with munchies everyday. The cozy garden /pool area is perfect for relaxing, eating breakfast and enjoying happy Hour. To sum it up this place was great, a block and a half off of Duvall Street in the heart of old town! PERFECT! Thanks Artist House!