The room was nice, and the high-altitude view completely met our expectations. However, those are pretty much the only positives. The issues we encountered far outweighed any good points.
1: Upon arriving at the lobby, there were three staff members chatting and laughing. Not one offered any guidance; instead, they simply told us to go 'around this way' to take the elevator. From that point on, for nearly a day and a night, almost no staff member proactively greeted us.
2: The butler didn't reply to messages. They advertise a 24-hour butler service, but a WeChat message sent at 8 PM wasn't answered until 11:30 PM, at which point I was informed they were off duty. I wonder if even when off duty, the account couldn't be handed over to a colleague to reply? Or if truly off duty, they could at least message to say 'please call the front desk.' But J Hotel's butler chose to simply not reply. When I addressed them politely in every message, the butler just used 'you' (the informal Chinese 'ni'), which felt very condescending. Even after checking out, they completely stopped replying to messages. I had wanted to ask for the name of the manager we spoke with to commend them, but sadly, I received no response.
3: There were no welcome fruits even though the 'Do Not Disturb' sign was off all day. After actively requesting room cleaning, the takeaway bags left on the floor were not removed, and the bedding wasn't changed. Even more unbelievably, during turndown service, there was a fake eyelash left by a previous guest on the mat where our personal toiletries were placed.
At 10 PM, after an exhausting discussion with the floor manager, I just wanted to wash up and rest. Unexpectedly, when I used a disposable toothbrush, bristles started falling out. This is a basic amenity issue that should never happen in any five-star hotel. By this point, I was utterly disappointed, all I wanted was to check out the next morning and leave this 'luxury' hotel that cost 4,000 yuan.
4: Breakfast was where I got the most direct experience of J's service. I was traveling with my girlfriend, and her cutlery was taken away when her plate was changed midway through. We were told, 'We'll get you new ones right away.' After waiting five minutes with no result, I waved to get a staff member's attention, but no one responded three times. The last time, a female staff member saw us but casually turned her head away. My girlfriend had to speak up and ask. This staff member just said 'Oh' and walked away, and for some unknown reason, never brought any cutlery. Both of us felt an unbearable sense of awkwardness, as if it were deliberate. By the time we finished eating, there was still only one set of cutlery on the table.
5: The only thing that could be called 'attentive' was when the manager came to negotiate and communicate at the end. This female manager occasionally interrupted to defend the hotel, but her overall attitude was sincere, and she apologized promptly. Unfortunately, after the resolution, the hotel transfer service she proactively offered was canceled because no vehicles were available at that time. It makes one wonder if a 4,000-yuan hotel is still worth it after so many unpleasant experiences. And being offered only an aromatherapy diffuser and a doll, items that cost the hotel almost nothing, just feels ridiculous.
I also have one final question: If my girlfriend and I weren't two seemingly young students, but rather 'esteemed' foreign guests, or VIP customers of the Jinjiang brand, would we still have been treated so perfunctorily, with even the resolution left unknown?
I want to know if J Hotel values ordinary guests, or if for J, the hotel's high altitude means its service attitude is equally high and mighty? If the warmth of hotel service cannot be conveyed to ordinary guests, then no matter how fancy the decor, it will fail to leave a lasting impression.
Original TextTranslation provided by AI