To ensure the authenticity of the displayed ratings, we do not simply calculate an average. Instead, we take into account the review credibility and the date of the guest's stay to determine the final rating.
Verified reviews
Location9.0
Amenities8.9
Service8.9
Cleanliness8.9
Filter by:
Sort by:
All reviews(102)
Positive reviews(14)
Reviews with photos/video(4)
Awesome rooms(6)
Great location(6)
Awesome amenities(5)
Guest User
One Bedroom Apartment
Stayed in Nov 2025
Couple
2 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Jan 13, 2026
This hotel is perfectly placed to explore the areas around South Yarra. The train station is a few minutes walk away at the top of the road on Toorak Road, with the CBD being only 2 stops away. It is just as easy to access other lovely areas around, such as Prahran Market, Brighton (famous beach huts) and many others. Staff at the hotel are very helpful and pleasant with nothing being too much trouble. The room was extremely comfortable with all amenities needed to make our stay comfortable. The bed was huge and extremely comfortable. There were facilities we didn't use, such as a gym.
Response from Property: Hi,Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback with us.We’re delighted to hear that you enjoyed your stay and that our team was able to provide attentive and helpful service. Comments like yours are greatly appreciated and motivate us to continue ensuring our guests have a comfortable and enjoyable experience.Kind Regards,Punthill South Yarra
Guest User
Studio Apartment
Stayed in Sep 2025
Solo traveller
33 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Oct 26, 2025
It was a great room, and great customer service! The bed was very soft and I love the views from the balcony
Response from Property: Dear Guest,Thank you very much for your kind words.We’re so pleased to hear that you enjoyed your stay and that both the room and the service met your expectations. It’s wonderful to know you found the bed comfortable and enjoyed the lovely views from the balcony — those small moments of comfort and relaxation are what we hope every guest experiences. Your feedback means a great deal to our team, and we truly look forward to welcoming you back for another enjoyable stay in the future.Kind Regards,Punthill South Yarra.
Seat 2A
One Bedroom Apartment
Stayed in May 2024
Solo traveller
37 review
7.0/10
Posted on Aug 4, 2024
Very conveniently situated beside a train station and tramt stop with abundant shopping and dining. A short walk away. My apartment clearly had not been clean thoroughly with food left in the fridge from a previous guest and bed sheets were not tucked in properly. Apartment looked dark and gloomy due to the colors of the carpet and Furniture with numerous scuff marks on the white walls. Maintenance needs some serious attention.
Response from Property: Hi, Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We’re pleased that you found our location convenient and enjoyed the proximity to shopping and dining options. However, we sincerely apologize for the issues you encountered during your stay.The cleanliness and upkeep of our apartments are top priorities, and we are disappointed to hear that we fell short in these areas. We have shared your concerns with our housekeeping and maintenance teams to ensure that such oversights do not happen again.Regarding the apartment's ambiance, we appreciate your comments about the décor. We are continuously working to improve our guests' experiences and will consider your feedback in future renovations.We hope to have the opportunity to welcome you back and provide you with a stay that meets the high standards we strive to maintain.Warm regards,Punthill South Yarra Grand
Guest User
Two Bedroom Apartment
Stayed in Dec 2023
Travelling with friends
10 review
9.5/10
Amazing
Posted on Jan 16, 2024
Well equipped with washing machine and DRYER(!!!) in the room. Excellent service and view from balcony.
Response from Property: Thank you for your rating. We appreciate your feedback and are glad you had a positive experience overall. If there's anything specific you'd like to share or any way we can improve, please let us know. We look forward to welcoming you back in the future.Punthill South Yarra
Anonymous User
Studio Apartment
Stayed in Oct 2023
Couple
3 review
7.0/10
Posted on Nov 11, 2023
serviced apartment
First of all, the location of the hotel is not very good. It is not in the CBD.
The lobby is well designed
The service is very good and very enthusiastic, but there is obviously not enough staff. There is only one person in charge of the front desk and room service.
The room is very large, with one bedroom, one living room, one balcony, one kitchen and one toilet. There is a washing machine and dryer.
But the facilities are very old, dirty and dilapidated. The room has a very uncomfortable smell. The wifi is very, very slow.
The bedding was not good and it was uncomfortable to sleep on.
All in all, I don’t recommend everyone to stay here.
Original textTranslated by Google
Response from Property: Dear Guest,Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback regarding your recent stay at our hotel-style apartment. We sincerely appreciate your detailed comments, and we extend our apologies for the challenges you encountered.We are pleased to hear that you found our lobby design appealing and our service warm and welcoming. However, we are genuinely sorry for the inconveniences you faced, such as the outdated and dirty facilities, the unpleasant odor in the room, and the slow WiFi.Your concerns are of utmost importance to us, and we assure you that we are taking immediate action to address these issues. We value your feedback as it helps us identify areas for improvement and ensure a more comfortable stay for our guests.We understand your hesitation in recommending our place, and we hope to have the opportunity to welcome you back in the future to showcase the improvements we have made.Thank you for choosing to stay with us.Warm regards,Punthill South Yarra Grand
Guest User
One Bedroom Apartment
Stayed in Dec 2024
Business traveller
6 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Mar 3, 2025
Very convenient, close to the station
Original textTranslated by Google
Response from Property: 感謝您的評論!我們很高興您發現我們的位置方便且靠近車站。我們期待您的光臨!
KennyLMK
Two Bedroom Apartment
Stayed in Jan 2024
Family
56 review
7.0/10
Posted on Mar 8, 2024
The room is large, has a terrace and a wide view. The kitchen is fully equipped, as well as a washer and dryer; in the bathroom, as expected, you must bring your own mouthwash supplies, and slippers are not provided. There are fewer shops nearby at night. There is a convenience store at the subway station next to it, but it is not open permanently. There is a supermarket about ten minutes' walk away that is open until midnight.
Original textTranslated by Google
Guest User
Two Bedroom Apartment
Stayed in Aug 2023
Family
1 review
6.0/10
Posted on Sep 26, 2023
The location was very convenient as it was close to the station. It was right next to the railroad tracks, but the noise didn't bother me.
Regarding the service, they did not come to clean the room according to the service information provided on the paper when I checked in.
The shower room was dusty and not very comfortable.
The windows were not curtains, but roll curtains, so the inside was completely visible from the outside.
The amenities did not include a toothbrush and slippers. I didn't have detergent to wash the dishes, so I called and was asked to come to the lobby to take pictures. I had just taken a bath and was wearing night clothes, so I went to pick it up the next morning.
Original textTranslated by Google
Response from Property: Dear guest,Thank you for sharing your feedback on your recent stay. We appreciate your positive comments about the convenient location and the minimal disturbance from nearby train tracks.We apologize for the lapses in service and cleanliness you experienced. It's disheartening to hear that the cleaning did not meet your expectations and that there were issues with the shower room. Rest assured, we will address these concerns with our housekeeping team to ensure a higher standard in the future.We also apologize for the inconvenience regarding the window coverings, amenity availability, and the dishwashing detergent. Your comments have been noted, and we will work towards improving these aspects of our service.Your feedback is invaluable, and we appreciate your understanding. If you decide to stay with us again, we're committed to providing a more satisfying experience.Warm regards,Punthill South Yarra Grand
Guest User
Two Bedroom Apartment
Stayed in Aug 2023
Business traveller
89 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Sep 15, 2023
Facilities: looks good
Hygiene: Hygiene is also very clean
Environment: The surrounding environment is very comfortable
Service: in place
Original textTranslated by Google
Response from Property: Hi,Thank you for taking your time to share these feedbacks.We are so glad that you had a pleasant stay. These kind words will give our staff motivation to work harder and deliver better services.We hope to see you next time!Warm regards,Jane Nguyen Punthill South Yarra Grand
Response from Property: Dear Guest,Thank you so much for your lovely feedback! We’re delighted to hear that you enjoyed your stay with us and found the room facilities convenient and comfortable. It’s wonderful to know our location and nearby dining options made your visit even easier. Your kind words truly mean a lot to our team. We hope to have the pleasure of welcoming you back again soon for another great stay!Kind Regards,Punthill South Yarra.
Guest User
Studio Apartment
Stayed in Aug 2025
Family
1 review
10/10
Outstanding
Posted on Oct 2, 2025
交通方便,出門就是火車站,出門就有中餐和白人餐,酒店衞生,餐具齊全,非常滿意
Translate
Response from Property: Thank you very much for your wonderful feedback. We’re delighted to hear that you enjoyed our convenient location, the nearby dining options, and the cleanliness and amenities of our apartments. We’re so pleased you had a satisfying stay and look forward to welcoming you again soon.