Hotel Sutter

Negative: I’m giving this property a three star rating for two reasons. The bed felt old and it had no back support. We had a very uncomfortable sleepless night. Morning, coffee, and muffins were distasteful. Positive : The location is spot on and the staff were friendly and professional.

Warm cozy comfortable bed and adequate bathroom facilities. Quiet when ready to sleep even though room above the bar area. Dinner was delicious.

Location was fantastic, right in the heart of town. The rooms were clean. The restaurant downstairs had amazing prime rib, desserts and service. We stayed for Christmas festivities in town and will definitely return.

Amazing cute, quaint hotel! So much character! Best part was the speak easy bar that we discovered last night. We loved it! Can’t wait to come back!

The staff was amazing. They were very helpful and met every need. The food was also wonderful. We ended up liking it so much that we ate there 3 times during our stay. Our biggest disappointment was the condition of the bed. It was very uncomfortable and swayed into the middle. Wife kept rolling into my during the nights. Updated bed would be ideal for this hotel.

Everything was fine. It was clean. We checked in late so we only saw the front desk staff who were trying to leave for the night. We had no other interaction with anyone. The speakeasy downstairs was great.

My husband and I try to come up to Sutter Creek three or four times a year and we will always check Hotel Sutter for a room before looking anywhere else. We love the old building, the friendly staff, the restaurant and the bar. Strolling the main street and visiting all the local shops.

The hotel is like a step back in time but with all modern amenities including an elevator. Staff was very friendly and accommodating, rooms were comfortable, AC worked very well, and restaurant food was very good. Would definitely stay here again!

Should do better. Room was too hot. AC was too noisy to have on. Windows did not open. Housekeeping did not complete the service. Toilets not cleaned. Coffee supplies not replaced.