Been coming here for years. Their thin crust is different, really crispy. Doesn&#39;t sit heavy in your stomach like some other places. Good when you want a pizza but don&#39;t feel like a whole NY slice.

The Glass Negroni here is so good. Perfectly balanced, not too bitter. I asked for a French 75 off-menu and they nailed it too. Their bar program is definitely the move.

The lamb sandwich was the star for me. Perfectly tender, and the Greek Cabernet they suggested paired so well. I&#39;ll be thinking about that combo for a while.

The back patio is a real find. So peaceful, tucked away from the street noise. Had a long, lazy lunch out there and it was just what I needed.

I had a great meal with a fun atmosphere. The service was top-notch, and I would definitely recommend this place for anyone looking for authentic Italian cuisine.

The daily specials are always interesting. I keep coming back for that Amsterdam Spicy Chicken.

Been coming here for years, and the penne vodka is always consistent. Hot, fresh, and the portion is just right for me. That&#39;s why I keep coming back.

The cheesecake case always looks so good. I tried the strawberry slice this time, it was nice. The tables are a little close together though, makes it hard to relax.

First visit to this location. Prime rib was cooked well, cocktails were good. Sat at the bar, service from Caitlin and Angela was efficient and friendly. Solid spot for a business dinner.

The food here is thoughtful. The grilled octopus had a perfect char, tender inside. The pasta was simple but the sauce had depth. You can tell they care about the ingredients.

Ordered a custom cake last minute, and they were super helpful. The cake was delicious, and the wine pairing suggestion they offered was spot on.

The owner came by to chat, super passionate about the food. The chicken and lentils were perfectly spiced, tasted just like a home-cooked meal. Really authentic vibe.

Been coming here for their Sunday brunch for years now. It&#39;s the view that keeps me coming back. That view over the water, it just makes the whole meal. The price is still fair, too.

The lunch specials are a solid deal. My falafel kabob was just right &ndash; crispy outside, soft inside. The modern space is a nice touch for a quick meal.

The separate dining room is a nice quiet spot. I grabbed a booth in there and it was way more chill than the main bar area. Good for when you just want to eat without all the game noise.

It gets pretty packed and loud in here, but honestly that&rsquo;s part of the fun. Finding a street spot nearby took me a few loops, but once you&rsquo;re in, the energy is great.

The view of the Hudson at sunset is just stunning. The whole space has this cozy yet polished feel, with really comfortable seating. It&#39;s a nice place to just sit and relax for a while.

Pizza was just okay this time. A bit inconsistent. But the steak sandwich? Delicious. That&rsquo;s the move.

Portions were huge. Chicken and gyro were solid. Got the platter and it was enough for two meals. That Mediterranean vibe felt real, not just decor.

Tried the takeout. Everything was ready in about 15 minutes and well-packaged. The Horiatiki salad with chicken was fresh and tasty. The gyro platter was satisfying, though the pita bread was a touch dry.

The family-style platters were so fresh and vibrant. Really appreciated the quality of the ingredients for our group.

Stopped by for lunch. Food was fresh, service was friendly. A nice, relaxed spot in Montclair.

Parking across the street is a huge plus. Grabbed a quick bite before heading to the Stadium last week. The burger was solid, cooked just right. A bit pricey for what it is, but the convenience is hard to beat.

Nice spot for a special dinner. The lighting is soft and the place feels cozy, not too loud. It&#39;s kept very clean. Had a business meal here and the atmosphere was just right for that.

The liver cubes with onions and tomatoes are a must. Labena with bread is super flavorful. Turkish martini comes with a piece of Turkish delight, nice touch. Everything came out fast, perfect for a quick lunch.

Stopped by for a quick bite. The kimchi carbonara was interesting, kinda worked? Cozy spot. Had to circle for street parking, that part wasn&rsquo;t fun.

The steak frites is why I keep coming back. Perfectly cooked medium-rare, the fries are crispy and salty. It&#39;s just a solid, reliable dish every single time.

The briochette French toast was the star. So fluffy, and the whipped cream was just right. The benedict and egg sandwich were good, but that French toast... I&#39;d come back just for that. Solid brunch spot.

The fish is always fresh. I go for the sashimi platter, the cuts are clean and the texture is right. Their special rolls are interesting, tried the one with yuzu kosho. It&#39;s a solid spot for the fish itself.

Loved the variety of tapas here, especially the seafood combo and octopus. The booths were really comfortable, which made a big difference for a relaxed dinner. Service was friendly and efficient.

Planning a Caldwell trip? Discover the best restaurants in Caldwell with traveller reviews, ratings, menus, photos and exclusive dining deals. Book tables instantly on Trip.com.

The best restaurants in Caldwell

Rizzo's Pizza

Sweet Afton

Ovelia

Stamatis

Ponte Vecchio Restaurant

Amsterdam Alley Bar & Restaurant

The Lazy Boy Saloon

The Cheesecake Factory

Houlihan's

Bareli's Restaurant and Bar

Swiss Chalet Bakery & Cafe

South Street Creamery

Waterside Events

THAVMA Mediterranean Grill

The Frog Restaurant and Sports Bar

Trattoria La Sorrentina

Fleming’s Prime Steakhouse & Wine Bar

Pier 115

Greek Taverna

Greek Taverna - Montclair

Fresco Da Franco

Halcyon

Giovanni's

Ruth's Chris Steak House

Bosphorus Cafe Grill

Prime & Beyond

BV Tuscany Restaurant

Patisserie Florentine - French Artisan Bakery & Brunch Café

Daruma

Pintxo y Tapas