The Coney Island dog here is the real deal. Snappy natural casing, that meaty chili sauce, just the right amount of onion. Been getting it for years. The coffee milk is a solid, classic pairing with it.

The outdoor tables by the harbor are the whole point. Got a spot just as the sun was dipping down, that golden light on the water&hellip; it was the vibe. A little breezy, but worth it for the view.

Find the best places for Dinner in Middletown. Explore 738 spots with authentic reviews from real users, compare menus and photos, and book your table instantly on Trip.com.

The Best Dinner in Middletown

Beach Bar

Moniker Brewery

Provolone's Italian Kitchen

Sea Craft

Chipotle Mexican Grill

Nice Slice Pizzeria

Trattoria Romana

Bangkok Republik

Yovanis Pizzeria

Sly Fox Den

Maven's Delicatessen

The Landing at Champlin's Marina & Resort

Filippou's Pizza Restaurant.

IL Forno Italiano

Linda's Diner

Sonic Drive-In

New England Frozen Lemonade

Original NY Systems

Faneek's

Hei Place

Smugglers Waterfront Bar

Sabitado's Pizzeria

Pizza Marvin

Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen

Central Pizza-Town Talk

Smitty's Pub & Pizza

David's Restaurant

Gone Country Creamery & Brys Pies

Cap't Loui

Casa Azul Taquería