Came here for a big anniversary dinner with a group of 20. The staff handled all our orders without any hiccups, which was impressive. For a place this nice, I was expecting the bill to be much higher.

Been coming here for years. The lobster roll pizza? Wasn&#39;t sure about it, but it&#39;s actually pretty good. The crust holds up well. Vodka lemonade pitcher is a solid choice, especially on a warm day.

Loved the moussaka! The Greek server was so happy when I ordered it, made my night. Pizza took a bit long, but it was a fun spot for our group.

Planning a Middletown trip? Discover the best restaurants in Middletown with traveller reviews, ratings, menus, photos and exclusive dining deals. Book tables instantly on Trip.com.

The best restaurants in Middletown

Buffalo Wild Wings

MoMo Sushi

parker. Eatery & Bar

Stowe's Seafood

Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale

Brazi's Italian Restaurant

Baingan Indian Cuisine

BAR

Anthony's of Guilford

Tandoor Rest Payphone

Yorkside Pizza & Restaurant

Pure Health Lounge

Portofino

Dad's Restaurant of Niantic

Crown Pizza

Burger King

Ibiza Restaurant Hamden

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

J Roo's Restaurant

Hamden Town House

Bellini's Restaurant

Ludal's Italian Restaurant

Ixtapa Grille Family Mexican Restaurant

The Brushmill by the Waterfall

Ristorante Luce

Mikro

Bobby Fritz Snack Bar

The Breakfast Nook

Brookside Inn Restaurant

Herb's Country Deli & Restaurant