First time here and the prime rib sandwich is huge! The meat was so tender and juicy, the horseradish gave it a nice kick. Honestly couldn&#39;t finish it all in one go, had leftovers for lunch.

Been here a few times now. The Bay View Burger is my go-to, and the Carolina Fried Chicken Sandwich never disappoints. Just solid food every time.

The server really knew her stuff about gluten and dairy allergies. She double-checked everything with the kitchen. Felt safe ordering, which was a relief.

The menu here is huge, which I love. So many interesting cocktails to choose from. My mezcal sour was perfectly balanced&mdash;not too sweet. Food was solid, but honestly, I could just come back for the drinks.

Service was on point for our date night. The cheese platter and potato soup were delicious, presentation was beautiful. But honestly, the portions felt a bit small for the price. Just left wanting a little more food.

Love the cozy, old-school vibe here. It feels like you&rsquo;ve stepped back in time the moment you walk in. Just a really charming spot with a nice mix of people.

Fun spot with solid food. Bartenders were attentive and quick with refills. Good for a casual weeknight dinner after work.

Tried their honey mustard for the first time and it&#39;s a game changer! The staff was really helpful in explaining the menu too.

The gluten-free menu markings were super clear, and the staff was really careful with my order. Felt totally at ease here.

Pano the owner is a good guy. He made our pasta just how we wanted it, even used fresh basil from his own garden out back. The pasta itself was really good.

Portions are generous here, and the ingredients always taste fresh.

Planning a Oconomowoc trip? Discover the best restaurants in Oconomowoc with traveller reviews, ratings, menus, photos and exclusive dining deals. Book tables instantly on Trip.com.

The best restaurants in Oconomowoc

Mimosa

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club

Casablanca Brookfield

Centraal Grand Café & Tappery

Lupi & Iris

Orenda Cafe

Wild Roots Restaurant

Zaffiro's Pizza The Original

The Old Rock

KJ's Bar & Grill

Cheba Hut "Toasted" Subs

Sushi Yuki

Famous Dave's Bar-B-Que

Outback Steakhouse

Club Paragon

Zebb’s Family Restaurant

IHOP

La Fuente Restaurant

Bruegger's Bagels

Cousins Subs

Benihana | Japanese Steakhouse

Real Chili | E Wells St at Cathedral Square

Chipotle Mexican Grill

Lisa's Pizzeria

Cousins Subs

Ally's Bistro

C. Wiesler's

Park Plaza Pizza

Harbor House by Bartolotta