Been coming here for years, and that ahi tuna never disappoints. It&#39;s always perfectly seared, just the right temperature. A solid choice after a hot day at the beach. The covered patio is a lifesaver for escaping the sun, too.

Came on a quiet evening, the new decor is really cozy. The stuffed shells were the standout for me - you could tell the filling was freshly made. Garlic knots had that nice, soft pull. Solid spot for a low-key dinner.

Had the Bissell Breakfast. The pancakes were fantastic, best in ages. Amy was a sweet, attentive server. The cook was impressively fast. Great value for the quality and quantity of food.

The Masaman curry was creamy and had a nice coconut flavor. Their house red wine was a surprisingly good match for it.

Been coming here for years. The portions are huge, always end up with leftovers. Prices haven&#39;t gone crazy like other places. Good for a solid meal.

First time trying hibachi here. The chef was super fun and kept us laughing the whole time. Food was solid, especially the fried rice. A bit loud, but that&#39;s part of the vibe.

After a rough start to the evening, this Denny&#39;s was a lifesaver. Kyle was running the whole floor by himself and still kept things moving. The real win was their surprisingly solid house red&mdash;it hit the spot and made the late-night burger actually work.

Kaylee was great at explaining the menu. She kept our drinks topped up and the table clear, which made a big difference.

The private room was a nice touch for our group. Service was smooth and attentive, even with so many of us. They kept things moving without feeling rushed.

As a northerner, I thought the pizza was pretty authentic. The vegan options, like the cauliflower starter, were a nice touch.

Stopped in for a burger and a beer. Potato skins were crispy, burger was juicy. Cold beer hit the spot. Lots of TVs for the game. Solid spot for a quick bite.

The spaghetti carbonara was really good, fresh ingredients. But for the price, I was expecting a bigger portion. Felt a bit light for a main course.

Parking&#39;s a breeze with the free garage next door. That alone makes heading downtown way less of a hassle.

The blackened grouper was so fresh and cooked just right. The booth seating was really comfortable, which made the whole meal feel relaxed. A nice, easy dinner.

The double smash burger was pretty good. Thin, crispy patties and fresh toppings. The coleslaw was decent, probably the best I had all week. A solid spot for a burger.

Came in after the renovation, the place looks nice. Ordered the eggplant rollatini as a starter. Honestly, for the price, the portion was a bit smaller than I expected. It was tasty, but I was still a little hungry after finishing it.

Love the vibe of this old gas station. The firepit and open garage doors make the outdoor seating feel so relaxed. Just a cool spot to hang out with friends.

Been coming here for years. David&#39;s always around, friendly guy. The pizza&#39;s the real deal - that sauce is something else. Dough&#39;s fresh, tastes like the old-school NJ pies. Solid spot.

Elijah was super helpful with the menu. Got my order in fast and the food came out quick. Perfect for a lunch break. Patio music was a nice bonus.

Been coming here for years, and the servers always know the seasonal menu inside out. Last night, our waiter suggested a wine that just clicked with the special. That kind of consistent, spot-on advice is why I keep coming back.

The burger was so good, especially the patty - juicy and flavorful. Fries were crispy, just how I like them. The music was a bit loud for chatting, but it had a fun, lively vibe.

The white pizza here is just so good. You can really taste the quality in the cheese and herbs. It&rsquo;s our new favorite for a reason.

Came in for the tonkatsu ramen. Broth was rich, really hit the spot on a chilly day. Place was cozy, lots of seats so didn&#39;t have to wait. Solid bowl.

The broth in their pho is pretty good, very flavorful. You can tell they put care into it. The noodles were a bit soft for my taste, but overall a solid bowl.

The grilled octopus was good, but the portion felt a bit small for the price. The homemade sauce was nice, sweet with a little kick. Just wish there was more of it on the plate.

First time. Cobb salad is huge, perfect for a quick lunch. The homemade blue cheese dressing is the star. Steak bomb sandwich was solid too. Good spot for a fast bite.

The fried mushrooms were a real standout. Came out piping hot, super crispy on the outside and juicy inside. Portion was generous for the price. A solid choice for sharing.

The Chicken Parmesan and Veal Marsala were spot on. Everything arrived piping hot, which was nice. Portions are definitely generous here.

Reservation was easy. Owner greeted us personally, which was a nice touch. Ordered the Chicken Mona Lisa and veal cacciatore. Portions are generous. Server Suzanne was efficient and handled everything well.

Server knew the menu inside out. Picked a wine that went perfectly with the steak. Attentive but not hovering. Made the whole thing easy.

Planning a Siesta Key trip? Discover the best restaurants in Siesta Key with traveller reviews, ratings, menus, photos and exclusive dining deals. Book tables instantly on Trip.com.

The best restaurants in Siesta Key

Freckled Fin Irish Pub

Scarpino's Classic Italian

Metro Diner

My Thai Restaurant | Thai Cuisine & Sushi

Pigout BBQ & Southern Soul Food

Daruma North Sarasota - Japanese Steakhouse & Sushi Lounge

Denny's

Melting Pot

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Rico's Pizzeria

Bogey's Sports Pub

Cafe Epicure

Bravo Pizza & Eatery

Tide Tables Restaurant and Marina

Ginny's & Jane E's Cafe and Gift Store

La Norma Ristorante & Pizzeria

Whitney's

Costello’s Neighborhood Pizza Longboat Key

Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria

Sage Restaurant

Food + Beer - Florida Sports Bar

Fresh Mozzarella Pizzeria

FushiPoke & Ramen

Little Saigon Cafe

Slicker's Eatery

Ken & Barb's Grove City Kitchen

IL Primo Pizza & Wings

Pesto Bistro and Wine Bar

Isabella's Bistro

Pietro’s Italian Restaurant and Wine Bar