The portions here are huge, definitely got our money&#39;s worth. We couldn&#39;t finish everything and ended up with a doggy bag. Left feeling stuffed and happy.

Great spot for a group dinner! We grabbed a table on the outdoor patio. The wagyu steak with truffle butter was so good we all shared bites. Cocktail list had some fun options too.

My go-to spot downtown for a quiet coffee. The matcha is smooth, not too sweet. I really appreciate the comfortable chairs and the staff is always so friendly. A nice place to just sit and be.

The Wednesday pot roast is huge. Seriously, a lot of food for the money. The meat is tender, falls apart with a fork. Good flavor in the gravy. That&#39;s the main thing I come for.

Love that they bring out warm chips and salsa right away! It&rsquo;s such a nice touch when you&rsquo;re catching up with friends. The place feels cozy and family-run, which makes it perfect for a relaxed hangout. The staff is super sweet, too.

Love the vibe here! Perfect for grabbing a slice with friends. The pizza is legit New York style, thin crust and loaded with toppings. The staff is super friendly, which makes hanging out even better. Just a cool, no-frills spot.

Carlene and Diane were attentive all evening. They kept our drinks refilled and timed the courses well. The service made a long business dinner feel efficient.

The tableside Caesar salad was the highlight for me. Watching them make it right there was so cool, and the dressing was just the right amount of tangy. A really fun part of the meal.

Will was our server. He gave us honest menu tips, which I liked. The gator bites and mahi tacos were solid. A good, straightforward meal.

The lunch special is solid, but ordering a whole pizza for extra toppings can be more cost-effective. You get leftovers too.

Been coming here for years. Amber, Tee, Brigette&mdash;they remember your drink, ask about your week. That kind of consistency is what keeps me coming back. Makes it feel like a neighborhood spot, even though it&#39;s right downtown.

The seafood was incredibly fresh, especially the oysters. A bit on the pricier side for a laid-back spot, but you taste it. The wine list had a nice crisp white that paired perfectly.

DJ Tony kept the energy up all night. The sound system was solid, and my meal was tasty with a generous portion. Fun spot!

The hot sandwich was delicious, but the portion felt a bit small for the price. I was still a little hungry after. The gelato was a nice treat though.

I order online for pickup all the time. They text when it&#39;s ready and bring it right to my car. Food&#39;s always cooked exactly how I ask.

Manager Ley checked on us a few times at lunch. Appreciate that. Got the oriental chicken salad and prime rib dipper - both were solid. Good to see the half-price apps are back. Quick, easy meal.

The lobster bisque was just right, not too salty. Found some decent-sized chunks of lobster in there too. A solid spot near the airport, and the view of the water is a nice touch.

Brian and Brady are so thoughtful. They remembered my usual order, which makes the whole experience feel personal and warm.

Alexa was our server and she was fantastic. Super friendly and energetic. She even surprised my husband with a little birthday treat, which was a really nice touch. Made the whole dinner feel a bit more special.

The inside is way nicer than you&#39;d expect from a plaza spot. Had the grilled octopus, it was cooked just right. Solid food, no complaints.

Perfect for a group hangout! We got seated fast with six, and the free chips with three salsas kept everyone happy while we chatted.

The vibe here is just so warm and inviting. I loved the way the light caught the edges of our plates, making everything look so pretty. Elexis was really sweet and attentive, which made the whole evening feel really nice.

The turmeric punch was a standout. Bartender really listened and adjusted the drinks to our liking. That extra touch made a difference.

The food quality here is impressive, with a diverse menu that caters to various tastes. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, making excellent recommendations that enhance the dining experience.

The 4-6pm happy hour is solid. The chicken tenders were juicy, and the fries came in this massive pile that just kept going. Perfect for sharing.

The eggplant parmigiana here is unreal. Seriously, that crispy pizza crust? Spot on. If you&#39;re into Italian, this is your spot.

The bourbon chicken skillet was fantastic. Judy suggested a nice red to go with it, which really hit the spot.

Been coming here for years, and the crab cakes are the reason. They&rsquo;re always just right&mdash;crispy outside, tender inside. Had them with a glass of their house white last Friday. It&rsquo;s my go-to for a relaxed dinner.

The fried haddock was so good, and the hand-breaded shrimp? Honestly the best I&#39;ve had. 😋 Prices are totally reasonable, which is great for grabbing a casual dinner with friends. We&#39;ll be back for sure!

Been coming here for years, and their Sicilian pizza never disappoints. The crust is just right, not too thick. It&#39;s my go-to spot when I just want something good and familiar.

Find the best places for Dinner in Siesta Key. Explore 718 spots with authentic reviews from real users, compare menus and photos, and book your table instantly on Trip.com.

The Best Dinner in Siesta Key

Nicola's Italian Kitchen

element steak. seafood. pasta.

ofKors BAKERY

The New Faull Inn

Paraiso Mexican Grille And Bar

Benny Bada Bings Pizza

Bob Evans

Marcello Ristorante

Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key

Patellini's Pizza

Lynches Pub & Grub

Phillippi Creek Oyster Bar

T J Carney's

Southside Deli

Outback Steakhouse

Applebee's Grill + Bar

Tarpon Bay Grill & Tiki Bar

Bamboo Island Bar

Carrabba's Italian Grill

Brine Seafood & Raw Bar

Takos Cantina Ranch Lake Blvd

Magnolias on the Bay

Turmeric Indian Bar & Grill

Post Kitchen and Bar

Tamiami Tap

Malmosto

Denny's Restaurant

Vino Loco Wine & Tapas

Sharks Fish House Restaurant

Zio’s Twelve 21 Pizzeria & Restaurant