The atmosphere at Matteo&#39;s is wonderfully warm, making it a great spot for gatherings. The food was amazing, and the staff was assertive and attentive, ensuring we had a fantastic experience.

The bartenders here are pretty good. They know the menu well and gave me a solid recommendation for a cocktail. Service was attentive without being overbearing. A nice spot for a quiet drink.

The brisket was really tender, and I appreciate that they use fresh, quality ingredients. The electric lemonade is a fun choice too.

Came in with low expectations but the steak sandwich was a total surprise. Cooked just right, juicy and the bread was perfect. Server was nice, got our food fast. Honestly way better than I thought it&#39;d be.

The fish tacos here are so good! We came with a group of friends and the vibe was perfect for catching up. Service was friendly and quick, which kept the conversation flowing. Will definitely be back for more of those tacos.

The portions here are seriously generous. I got the chicken parm, and it was so big I had to take half of it home. It made for a great lunch the next day, honestly.

The lobster roll was a decent size, though a bit pricey. The booths were comfortable, which made the meal really pleasant.

Valet parking was a nice touch, made it easy. The place does fill up, so I&#39;m glad we had a reservation. Our server was really friendly and patient while we decided.

Remi and Alvaro really know their stuff. They suggested the bone marrow appetizer, which I wouldn&#39;t have ordered. It was rich and savory, exactly what I wanted. Their recommendations are spot on.

Been coming here for years. The regular and Sicilian pizzas are always solid. Crust has good chew, sauce is flavorful. That&#39;s really all I need.

The Baymen&#39;s Best is a solid choice if you&#39;re hungry. Got a huge portion of mussels, and they even throw in extra bread for dipping. Prices felt fair for what you get.

Ate here on a sunny afternoon by the water. The oysters were the highlight for me&mdash;so fresh and clean-tasting. The fried calamari was crispy, but I personally prefer lighter options. A nice spot if you&#39;re craving fresh seafood.

Noel was our server and his menu suggestions were really helpful. He guided us to a couple of dishes we wouldn&#39;t have tried otherwise, and they were just right. It made the whole dinner so relaxed and easy.

The Palma is a standout cocktail. Margherita pizzette was great, but the music was a bit loud for conversation.

Breakfast sandwich on a brioche bun is the move. Perfectly fluffy, good coffee. My go-to spot for a quick morning bite.

The pasta portions are huge here, always have leftovers to take home!

I was craving a burger and this place hit the spot. The patty was juicy, and the fries were crispy. They even have a solid vegan patty option, which is nice for my friend. The portion was generous for the price. I left feeling full and satisfied.

The sunset over the water was lovely. I appreciated how fresh the ingredients in my salad tasted, it really complemented the peaceful setting. A nice, simple meal.

Nice patio for lunch meetings when the weather&#39;s good. Quiet enough to talk, decent view. Food was fine, service was prompt. A solid option if you need a convenient spot downtown.

I had an incredible experience at Arlo&#39;s for my anniversary. The ambiance is classy and romantic, and the staff went above and beyond to make our night special. The cocktails were delightful, and the food was perfect!

Linette was great, she really knew the menu. The grilled octopus she suggested was spot on, perfectly charred and tender. That&#39;s what I came for.

Been coming here for years. The shrimp po&#39;boy is the reason why. The shrimp are always cooked just right, never rubbery, and the seasoning is spot-on. It&#39;s the one thing I can count on every single visit.

The firecracker shrimp with Thai chili glaze was pretty good. It had a nice kick and the flavor was solid. A decent starter. The portion felt a bit small for the price, though.

Find and book the best Restaurants in Bellport. Read authentic reviews from real users, compare menus and photos, and reserve your table instantly on Trip.com.

The Best Restaurants in Bellport

Matteo's of Huntington

Top of the Bay Bistro

Krisch's

Vittorio's

Maxwell's

Bobbique

Castaway Bar & Grill

Albatross

Original Michelangelo Pizzeria-Restaurant Eastport

Cowfish

La Parma II Italian Restaurant

Pasta Pasta

Sant Ambroeus Southampton

Gino's of Nesconset

Varney's Restaurant

Skippers

Pasta-eria

Locale Gastro Bar and Pizzette

The Hamlet

Michelangelo Pizzeria

Hamptons Farms

The Oar Steak & Seafood Grille

Grasso's

Arlo Kitchen & Bar

Island Breeze

BayVue

The Lazy Lobster

Da Noi Italian Restaurant

Matthew's

John Scott's Surf Shack