The food here is so good! Everything we ordered had this perfect balance of flavor, not too heavy or sweet. It was the ideal spot for catching up with friends over a great meal. The staff was super nice and gave us some solid suggestions too.

Huge sandwiches for the price. The fried pickles were the best part, honestly. Crispy, tangy, not greasy. That&#39;s what I&#39;ll remember.

Been coming here for years. The grilled fish is always solid - crispy outside, tender inside. The dill in the tartar sauce is a nice touch. Just a good, reliable meal.

The short ribs were so tender they fell apart. Mashed potatoes were smooth and rich. Also tried the butternut squash risotto - creamy and hearty, a solid veggie choice.

Service was prompt and efficient. Staff was attentive without being intrusive. Food came out quickly, and it was clearly made fresh. Good for a business lunch when you&#39;re on a tight schedule.

Been coming here for years, and those fresh-cut fries are the reason. Doesn&#39;t matter how packed it gets on a Saturday, they&#39;re always piping hot and crispy. That kind of consistency keeps me coming back.

Came here for brunch with my friends last weekend. The eggs benedict was spot on, and the french toast? So fluffy. Coffee kept us chatting for hours. Perfect for a lazy catch-up.

The barramundi special was pretty good. Fish was nicely seasoned and cooked well. The potato cake and spinach on the side were a decent match. A solid choice for a simple dinner.

Got the free valet parking for 3 hours with my reservation. The food was solid, everything was just easy. Good spot when you want a nice dinner without overthinking it.

That duck fat fried chicken is a winner. The crust was super crispy without being greasy at all, and the meat inside stayed really juicy. The spicy chili sauce on the side was a good match for it.

Nice spot tucked away in the hotel. Quiet enough to actually hear each other talk. Had the grilled salmon, it was cooked just right. A bit on the pricey side for what you get, but the vibe was solid.

Service was very professional. The crab soup was excellent, but the main course arrived a bit later than expected. Staff handled it well. Good spot for a business dinner.

The Sriracha buttermilk fried chicken and waffles are a solid choice. The dark meat was juicy and had a nice kick. Waffles were crispy on the outside, fluffy inside. A bit pricey for the portion, but I&#39;d order it again.

Sat outside for a late lunch, the view over the water was lovely. Had the grilled octopus, which paired surprisingly well with their house ros&eacute;. A bit pricey for the portion, but the drink made it work.

The scallops were a highlight for me. They were seared just right, not greasy at all. What I really appreciated were the fresh, seasonal accompaniments. A nice, elegant option for a lighter meal.

Booked ahead, got seated right away. The creamy onion and black garlic soup was a standout, really nice. The black bean burger was good too, solid sauce for the potatoes.

The dim lighting and intimate setting really set the mood for a quiet dinner. Felt like a cozy, tucked-away spot you&#39;d want to keep to yourself.

Ordered the chicken parm for a group event. The chicken was surprisingly tender and the tomato sauce tasted really fresh. It was easy to pick up and set out. Everyone enjoyed it.

The lava cake was so warm and gooey inside, and the cold ice cream with it was just right. The whole dessert was a nice, cozy way to end the meal.

The vibe here is so cozy, perfect for a chill dinner. I was really into their truffle pasta &ndash; the sauce was creamy but not heavy, and you could actually taste the truffle. Portion was just right for me.

The staff here are genuinely nice. Our server and the chef both came by to chat for a bit, which was a really nice touch. It made the whole dinner feel more welcoming and personal.

Been coming here for years, the food is always solid. Big portions, rich flavors. My go-to is the house red with the braised short rib &ndash; just works. A bit noisy on weekends, but that&#39;s Ithaca for you.

Nice spot for a quiet Sunday lunch. The view of the lake from the tables is solid. Food was decent, a bit on the simple side for the price. Service was efficient.

The cumin lamb was spot on, really tender and fragrant. The spicy chicken had a nice kick too, came out piping hot. Solid choice for Chinese food around here.

Cozy spot with rustic vibes. Came for a casual dinner with a friend. The wall paintings really caught my eye, gave the place a lot of character. Food was solid.

Host was cool about the wait. Margaritas hit the spot. Mole was solid. Sat outside, good for people watching.

Been coming here for years. The owner always remembers my name and asks how my week&#39;s been. That kind of personal touch is what keeps me coming back. Feels like a real neighborhood spot.

Love the build-your-own pizza option. Got a garlic base with olives, ricotta, and pineapple&mdash;the flavors just worked.

The chicken enchiladas were pretty good. Our server was very friendly and made the evening nice and smooth.

Find the best places for Dinner in Ithaca. Explore 162 spots with authentic reviews from real users, compare menus and photos, and plan your perfect dining experience.

The Best Dinner in Ithaca

Taste of Thai

Gorgers

The Boatyard Grill

Mercato Bar & Kitchen

Collegetown Bagels

Purity Ice Cream Co.

Simeon's American Bistro

Maxie's Supper Club & Oyster Bar

Taverna Banfi

The Rook

Monks on the Commons

Mia Restaurant

MIX

Ithaca Ale House

Le Café Cent-Dix

Moosewood

Gola Osteria Restaurant & Catering

Sal's Pizzeria

Chili's Grill & Bar

Ithaca Social

The State Diner

Sangam Indian Cuisine

Sunset Grill

De Tasty Hot Pot Restaurant

Hawi

Chatty Cathy Coffee & Juice Press

Viva Taqueria & Cantina

Souvlaki House

Franco's Pizzeria

Bickering Twins Restaurant & Tequila Bar