Love that they bring out warm sourdough with herbed olive oil right when you sit down. It&#39;s such a good way to kick off a catch-up dinner with friends. We ended up asking for a second basket!

Roger was our server, super friendly guy. The fall cocktail menu had a great Spiced Pear, light and delicious. It paired nicely with the stuffed mushrooms, which are still a must-try. A solid spot for a drink and a bite.

Stuffed French toast was phenomenal. Rich and flavorful.

The chicken sandwich is hand-breaded and the chips are homemade, which is nice. But for $18, I was hoping for a slightly bigger portion. It&#39;s tasty, just left wanting a bit more.

The coffee at this spot is honestly the best I&#39;ve had in Gambier. Stew at the counter was super friendly and knew his stuff. My latte had this perfect, velvety foam.

Tiffany at the bar is the best. She remembered my name from last time, and her drink recommendation was spot on. Makes the whole place.

First time here and I was impressed with the allergy care. My friend has a gluten issue, and the server walked us through the menu, pointing out safe options. They even checked with the kitchen. Felt really taken care of.

The $6 drink specials are a total win for a casual hangout. We grabbed a table downstairs in the old jail area&mdash;the exposed brick and low lighting made it feel really cozy for catching up. The vibe was just right.

The mushroom appetizer was fantastic. So delicate, with a nice texture. Drinks were clearly made with care. Service was attentive without being overbearing. A really pleasant spot for a relaxed evening.

Huge slices of cheesecake during the half-off special. Tried a few flavors. The homemade ones are definitely the best thing here. Really solid.

The thin crust pepperoni pizza was pretty good. The crust was nice and crispy, and the cheese-to-sauce ratio was just right. A solid choice for a casual meal.

Been coming here for years. The frozen yogurt is always solid, no weird aftertaste like some other places. My go-to for a quick, reliable treat.

The chicken alfredo is my go-to here. The sauce is rich and creamy without being too heavy, and they don&#39;t skimp on the chicken. The Philly cheesesteak sub is a solid choice too. Good to have options beyond just pizza.

The armadillo eggs are back! They actually called me when they were in stock again. The vibe in here is just right for a casual bite - not too loud, and the booths are super comfy.

Finally got to try the dine-in after the re-opening! The booths are so comfy, and you can tell it&#39;s a real local hangout. Perfect for catching up with friends over a meal. Staff was super nice too.

Flappers is my spot. The Greek salad is always fresh, and the portion is just right for what you pay. Love the energy when a band plays, it just feels good.

Your ultimate guide to dining in Mansfield. Discover top-rated restaurants and local favorites, based on authentic traveler ratings and reviews. ▸ See menus & photos ▸ Find hidden gems ▸ Plan your perfect trip.

The best restaurants in Mansfield

The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Mansfield

UNCLE JOHN’S PLACE

Swavory

Martini's On Main

Smokin Bros BBQ Voted # 1

Rancho Fiesta

Deschner’s

Bob Evans

Coney Island Inn - Mansfield, OH

Reindeer Grill

Deja Food Eatery & Cebuano Bar

Cypress Cellars

Broken Rocks Café & Bakery

The Copper Mug

The City Square Steakhouse

Kenyon Inn & Restaurant

Gambier Deli

Rox Gastropub

Dave's Cosmic Subs - Mt Vernon

The Granary Restaurant at Pine Tree Barn

Olde Jaol Steakhouse and Tavern

Lyn-Way Restaurant - Ashland, OH

The Alcove Restaurant & Lounge

Wishmaker House

Donatos Pizza

EVA's Treats

Fast Eddie's Pizza

Omahoma Bobs BBQ

Coccia House

Flappers Bar and Grille