The pizza here is solid&mdash;fresh ingredients and ready in 20 minutes. The staff was really nice, too.

The raspberry donut from the local menu was so good! They make them fresh right there. We grabbed a table on the back deck with friends, and the view of the lake was just perfect for a chill afternoon.

Nice spot by the water. Grabbed a cone and sat outside. The view was chill, perfect for just zoning out with some ice cream. Simple and pleasant.

Stopped in after hiking Swallow Falls. That pulled chicken sandwich with the apple butter BBQ sauce is a winner. Had a Hefeweissbier with it&mdash;solid choice, ended up grabbing a six-pack to go.

Seafood tower was solid, but the scallop ceviche really stood out. Fresh, bright, with a perfect little kick. That one stuck with me.

Found this spot on a quick lunch run. The vintage gas station vibe is cool. Got the iced vanilla latte - smooth and hit the spot. Cinnamon roll was warm and tasty. Perfect for a fast bite.

Loved the vegan options here! The mushroom &quot;chicken&quot; sandwich was so good&mdash;the texture was spot on, and the sauce had a nice kick to it. Really glad they have choices like this.

I always enjoy coming here. The macaroni salad is really good&mdash;it&rsquo;s a shame it&rsquo;s not a regular menu item. Everything else is consistently fine.

The Orchard&#39;s Edge cocktail was really good. Solid old fashioned too.

Your ultimate guide to dining in McHenry. Discover top-rated restaurants and local favorites, based on authentic traveler ratings and reviews. ▸ See menus & photos ▸ Find hidden gems ▸ Plan your perfect trip.

The best restaurants in McHenry

Falls Market Restaurant & Inn

Falls City Pub & Restaurant

Pizza Hut

Deep Creek Donuts

Sirianni's Café

Ohiopyle House Cafe

Lakeside Creamery

Mountain State Brewing Co

Aqueous

Lake House Restaurant

Wicked Wilderness Pub

The Ice Cream Shop

Castiglia | Italian Eatery

Fuel Coffee Works

Elender’s Global Cuisine

Paddlers Pizza

Casselman Bakery and Café

Firewater Kitchen & Bar

Ledo Pizza

Mae’s Restaurant

Candlewyck Inn

Stumptown Ales

The Corner Bistro & Vintage Market

Fox's Pizza Den

Tropics

Walzzy’s Hotdogs

Dockside Grille

Fox's Pizza Den

Picnic

Fat Angelo's