Stopped in on a road trip. The pizza really stood out&mdash;thin, crispy crust, great balance of sauce and cheese. Calamari was fresh, not rubbery at all. A solid find off the highway.

Staff was super friendly, not pushy at all. I asked for a gluten-free bun and they were really careful about it, which I appreciate. Felt like they actually listened. Nice spot to chill.

Love the rustic feel here. The outdoor patio is definitely one of the best in the area. Those heat lamps and fire pits are a lifesaver when it gets chilly. The Halloween decorations were a nice, fun touch too.

The carnitas tacos here are the real deal. Slow-cooked pork with crispy edges, fresh cilantro and onion, and a squeeze of lime. The corn tortillas are soft and warm. That&#39;s what I come for. The salsa verde has a nice kick to it.

The outdoor seating is nice, and the live folk music was a pleasant surprise. Food was pretty good, though the service felt a bit slow. A solid spot for a relaxed evening.

Solid pub food, good prices. My girlfriend and I popped in on their tiki night&mdash;those rum cocktails were a fun surprise. We&#39;ll probably swing by again.

Your ultimate guide to dining in Pine Hill. Discover top-rated restaurants and local favorites, based on authentic traveler ratings and reviews. ▸ See menus & photos ▸ Find hidden gems ▸ Plan your perfect trip.

The best restaurants in Pine Hill

Picnic Pizza

MaMa’s Trattoria

Crazy River Cafe & Deli

Uptown Coffee

Buns Burgers

Mario's Pizza

The Mud Club Woodstock

Reservoir Inn

Piccolo Trattoria

Nardi's Italian Restaurant

River Pavilion at Hutton Brickyards

Phoenicia Pizza 28

La Cabana

VanWinkle's at the Kaatskill Mountain Club

Aroma Thyme Bistro

Main Street

Diego's Taqueria

Higher Grounds Coffee Co.

Angela's Pizza

J Roccos

Di Bella's

Enzo's Ristorante & Pizza

Rail Trail Cafe

Stella's Station

Rough Draft Bar & Books

The Old Mill

Asia

Golden Ginza

The Grahamsville Deli

Binnekill Tavern