The atmosphere at Matteo&#39;s is wonderfully warm, making it a great spot for gatherings. The food was amazing, and the staff was assertive and attentive, ensuring we had a fantastic experience.

The bartenders here are pretty good. They know the menu well and gave me a solid recommendation for a cocktail. Service was attentive without being overbearing. A nice spot for a quiet drink.

Lisa was super helpful with the margarita recommendation. The service was really attentive.

Came in with low expectations but the steak sandwich was a total surprise. Cooked just right, juicy and the bread was perfect. Server was nice, got our food fast. Honestly way better than I thought it&#39;d be.

The fish tacos here are so good! We came with a group of friends and the vibe was perfect for catching up. Service was friendly and quick, which kept the conversation flowing. Will definitely be back for more of those tacos.

Came here for a casual lunch and tried the steamed mussels. They were cooked perfectly, and the broth was so rich and buttery. I could just drink it on its own. Friendly service, too.

Been coming here for years, and those garlic knots with cheese are still the reason. They never miss.

The tomato balsamic pizza was really good. But what got me was the crust&mdash;thin, crisp, and held up perfectly. Just a solid slice.

Valet parking was a nice touch, made it easy. The place does fill up, so I&#39;m glad we had a reservation. Our server was really friendly and patient while we decided.

Been coming here for years. The fish tacos are always fresh, and my wife loves the fried scallops. Prices are fair for what you get.

First time trying this place and loved the outdoor seating by the water. The old brick building and that vintage door at the entrance gave it a cool vibe. Perfect for a summer evening.

Ate here on a sunny afternoon by the water. The oysters were the highlight for me&mdash;so fresh and clean-tasting. The fried calamari was crispy, but I personally prefer lighter options. A nice spot if you&#39;re craving fresh seafood.

Had the blackened swordfish. The fish itself was so fresh, you could really taste it. The seasoning was light, which I appreciated. It came with a simple side of grilled vegetables, all very crisp. A nice, clean meal. The view from our window table was a bonus.

Quick lunch spot. Got the chicken sandwich. Came out fast, which is key for me. Bread was fresh, chicken was decent. Not the cheapest but you pay for the speed. Good for a quick bite between meetings.

Been coming here for years. They keep the quality consistent, which is what keeps me coming back. The open garage doors are a nice touch, especially in the evening. Food&#39;s always solid.

Been coming here for years, and the sushi&#39;s always fresh. That eel sauce on the maki combo? Still the best in town. It&#39;s why I keep coming back.

Great happy hour spot. The margaritas are strong and the guacamole is fresh. Nice harbor view too.

Been coming here for years. Their lemon potatoes are still the best in town. Perfectly cooked, just the right amount of seasoning. That&#39;s what keeps me coming back for a simple lunch.

Our server really knew her stuff. She explained the spicy margarita in detail&mdash;all-natural ingredients, house-infused chili. It was balanced, not just heat. She also noticed I was eyeing the menu and gave a perfect suggestion. Made the whole visit smooth.

Find the best places for Dinner in Suffolk County. Explore 1134 spots with authentic reviews from real users, compare menus and photos, and book your table instantly on Trip.com.

The Best Dinner in Suffolk County

Matteo's of Huntington

Top of the Bay Bistro

Vittorio's

Goccia D'Oro

Post Office Café

Nicky’s on the Bay

The Snapper Inn

Maxwell's

Peter Pan Diner

Castaway Bar & Grill

Albatross

Shagwong

La Scala Ristorante Pizzeria

Mario's Pizzeria of Commack

Piccolo

La Parma II Italian Restaurant

Clam and Chowder House at Salivar's Dock

Rockin' Fish

Skippers

The Ritz Cafe

Cherry's On The Bay

Tula Kitchen

Mitsui Japanese Restaurant

K Pasa

NOCO

Pietro Cucina Italiana

Go Greek

Léon 1909

Windamere

Little Fish