Trip
Travel guides
North America
United States
Florida
Sumter County
Trip.com Gourmet Awards
Recommended Restaurants in Sumter County for September

The best restaurants in Sumter County

Opening hours

Open Now
0:00 AM～5:00 AM
5:00 AM～10:00 AM
10:00 AM～2:00 PM

Updated in September 2026

O'Keefe's Irish Pub & Restaurant

4.4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Bars/bistros
££-£££
Currently closed (16:00-21:00)
130m from downtown

La Casa Mexican Bar and Grill

4.3/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Latin American cuisine
£
Currently closed (11:00-21:00)
300m from downtown

Taverna Manos

4.4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
££-£££
Currently closed (17:00-19:30)
1.2km from downtown

Kilwins Ice Cream - Chocolate - Fudge

4.4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
££-£££
Currently closed (11:00-21:00)
3km from downtown

Florida Cracker Kitchen

4.7/5
Amazing
7 reviews
󱵁Bars/bistros
£
Currently closed (7:00-14:30)
689m from downtown

The Bistro

4.4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
£
Currently closed (11:00-21:00)
25m from downtown

Kafe Kokopelli

4.4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
££-£££
Currently closed (11:00-21:00)
877m from downtown

The Tilted Teacup Tea Room and Boutique

4.8/5
Amazing
8 reviews
󱵁Bakery
££-£££
Currently closed (11:00-15:00)
662m from downtown

PRESS'D Juice Bar & Kitchen

4.4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Bakery
£
Currently closed (8:30-19:00)
513m from downtown

Coney Island Drive Inn

4.6/5
Amazing
7 reviews
󱵁Snacks
£
Currently closed (10:00-21:00)
674m from downtown

Tiki West Raw Bar and Grill

4.4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Seafood
££-£££
Currently closed (11:00-21:00)
349m from downtown

Chicken Salad Chick

4.5/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Quick bites
£
Currently closed (10:30-19:00)
2.5km from downtown

Shiva Indian Restaurant

4.1/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Southeast Asian cuisine
££-£££
Currently closed (12:00-15:00)
118m from downtown

Puddle Jumpers Lakeside Grill & Bar

4.3/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Seafood
££-£££
Currently closed (11:00-22:00)
305m from downtown

Fish Camp Lake Eustis

4.3/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Quick bites
£
Currently closed (11:00-20:00)
1.2km from downtown

Eaton's Beach Sandbar & Grill

4.6/5
Amazing
7 reviews
󱵁Barbecue
££-£££
Currently closed (11:00-21:00)
22.3km from downtown

BurgerFi

4.7/5
Amazing
7 reviews
󱵁Quick bites
££-£££
Currently closed (11:00-21:00)
457m from downtown

Village Coffee Pot of Mount Dora

4.4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Bakery
£
Currently closed (8:00-21:00)
35m from downtown

Scoops on 5th

4.4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
£
Currently closed (12:00-21:00)
52m from downtown

Rookies Family Grille & Bar

4.3/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
£
Currently closed (11:00-21:00)
5.5km from downtown

Olive Branch Mediteranean - Italian

4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Bars/bistros
££-£££
Currently closed (11:30-21:00)
121m from downtown

PizzAmoré

4.5/5
Great
4 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
££-£££
Currently closed (15:00-21:00)
712m from downtown

Angel Tea Room & Heavenly Treasures Gift

4.7/5
Amazing
7 reviews
󱵁Teahouse/Tea room
££-£££
Currently closed (11:00-16:00)
726m from downtown

Energy Lab Cafe

4.4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Coffee shop
££-£££
Currently closed (07:00-19:00)
412m from downtown

Dirty Richard's Pizza Shop & Pub

4.7/5
Amazing
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
£
Currently closed (11:00-21:00)
988m from downtown

El Marie Pizzeria and Sub Shoppe

4.7/5
Amazing
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
£
Currently closed (11:00-20:00)
71m from downtown

First Watch

4.3/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
£
Currently closed (7:00-14:30)
7.3km from downtown

Marcelina's Italian Restaurant

4.8/5
Amazing
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
£
Currently closed (14:00-21:00)
15.7km from downtown

American Pizza Oven

4.7/5
Amazing
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
£
Currently closed (11:00-20:00)
878m from downtown

The Hangry Bison - Winter Garden

4.3/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Quick bites
£
Currently closed (11:00-23:59)
259m from downtown