We came here three times in one week, which says a lot. The Greek salad was fresh, really fresh&mdash;the tomatoes actually tasted like something. My friend had a steak one night and it was cooked properly, not overdone. Wine list is decent too, better than what you usually find around here. Service was quick, maybe a little too quick at times, but fine.

The pizza here is seriously good for such a tiny island. Crust was spot on and toppings tasted fresh. Great spot to grab a bite with friends 🍕

The gyros and moussaka were solid&mdash;flavors were there, no complaints. Prices felt fair for what you get, portion was decent. Service was quick too.

The aperol spritz at Stelios is the best I&#39;ve had on the island. Proper balance, not too sweet, ice actually cold. Bartender knows what he&#39;s doing. That&#39;s it. That&#39;s the review.

Great Motown night, staff proper friendly. Christos knows his stuff. Felt looked after all evening.

Stopped by for dinner on a work trip. The grilled octopus was spot on, and the house wine didn&rsquo;t disappoint. Service was quick, which I appreciated since I was short on time. Prices felt fair for what you get. Nothing fancy, but it does the job well.

Your ultimate guide to dining in Ithaca. Discover top-rated restaurants and local favorites, based on authentic traveler ratings and reviews. ▸ See menus & photos ▸ Find hidden gems ▸ Plan your perfect trip.

The best restaurants in Ithaca

Megas

Catamaran - Greek & Italian Cuisine

Ta Kavourakia

Tranquilo

Coyote Pizzeria

Sti Ladokola

Giovannis Grill House

Gogos Gefsis

Avra Taverna

Old Time Cafe

Pizza Da Domenico

Captain's Corner

To Monastiri Souvlatzidiko

Taverna Galini

Τo Lefko Akrogiali

Gialos Cafe Bar

Cavo

Bello Pizza Restaurant

Maistros Taverna

Kath'odon

Taverna Ranzio Ionio

Elite Cafe Bar

Libre Cafe

Loco Bar

Deck

Alia's Yard Restaurant & Bar - Magganos

MENTIS

Let it be - Bistro & Wine Garden

Ikaros Cafe

Yummy Yogurt