The Manhattan Club

The Manhattan Club Reviews

The Manhattan Club

200 W 56th St, New York, New York State, 10019View Hotel Details
The Manhattan Club
The Manhattan ClubThe Manhattan ClubThe Manhattan Club
Check available rooms for your travel dates
We Price Match
1 night

The Manhattan Club Guest Reviews

4.1/5
Very Good
137 review
Verified reviews
Location4.1
Amenities4.1
Service4.2
Cleanliness4.2
Filter by:
Sort by:
All reviews(137)
Positive reviews(34)
Reviews with photos/video(14)
Awesome rooms(10)
Great location(10)
Awesome stay(8)
Clean and tidy(6)
Friendly host(5)
Negative reviews(3)
MAHATANASAB
Executive Junior Suite
Stayed in Jun 2024
Travel with friends
1 review
5.0/5
Outstanding
Posted on Jul 27, 2024
Very good place to stay
Response from Property: Thank you for choosing us as a part of your NewYork City experience, we hope you'll see us againduring your next stay.
giuseppe
Metropolitan Suite
Stayed in Oct 2023
Business travellers
23 review
5.0/5
Outstanding
Posted on Dec 18, 2023
Best place to stay downtown
CHANCECHIEH
Executive Junior Suite
Stayed in Feb 2025
Couples
5 review
5.0/5
Outstanding
Posted on Mar 29, 2025
Great experience! It is really rare to find such a large room at a reasonable price in Manhattan, where every inch of land is valuable! Recommended to everyone! Will stay here again when visiting New York!
Original TextTranslated by Google
Response from Property: Thank you for choosing us as a part of your NewYork City experience, we hope you'll see us againduring your next stay.
Pangdingpangniu
One Bedroom Suite
Stayed in Jul 2024
Family
7 review
5.0/5
Outstanding
Posted on Sep 6, 2024
The location is super convenient. You can walk to all the places we want to go: Columbus Circle, Central Park, Times Square, Moma, Fifth Avenue. There is a Starbucks and Deli downstairs, so breakfast is very convenient. There are many delicious restaurants within a ten-minute walk: pasta, pizza, ramen, you won't go wrong. There is also a summer market on Seventh Street on weekends, with all kinds of small things, snacks, and performances.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Response from Property: Thank you for choosing us as a part of your NewYork City experience, we hope you'll see us againduring your next stay.
Fenfangdeweixiao
One Bedroom Suite
Stayed in Jul 2024
Family
5 review
3.2/5
Posted on Sep 4, 2024
The hotel is in a prime location, close to Central Park, Times Square, and Broadway, which can be reached in a few minutes on foot. The surrounding facilities are complete, and various restaurants and shops are available. The hotel lobby is very small and old-fashioned, with basically no service. Three people stayed in a suite with a sofa bed in the living room. The living room and bedroom are connected by a corridor. There is a small dining table for four people and a long corridor bar, two small niche wardrobes, and two toilets are the best. The bedroom is small and the layout is very regular. The living room door is directly opposite the sofa bed without transition. There are noisy sounds outside the door and outside the house at night. The hotel is not very comfortable and elegant, but with a limited budget, it is a good choice for tourists who love the convenient central location and need a more spacious space! After all, it is in the capital of the world.
Original TextTranslated by Google
6/10
Response from Property: We appreciate the time you took to leave us a kind review, we hope you'll see us again during your next stay.
Anonymous User
Executive Junior Suite
Stayed in Jul 2024
Family
50 review
3.5/5
Posted on Aug 11, 2024
The hardware location is perfect, the front desk service is super perfect, the only bad thing is the room service, it's terrible. Location: Opposite the Carnegie Theater, very close. Two blocks away from Columbus Circle, very safe. Such a high-priced place actually has a hotel as big as a one-bedroom and one-living room, 46 square meters really feels full of space. Configuration: The sofa bed is not an ordinary one, it is very large and sturdy after opening, much larger than the single bed in most hotels. Coffee machine, coffee capsules, cutlery dishwasher, microwave. Dining table, each room has a TV, and there are many channels. The one-bedroom has two bathrooms, one shower and one bathtub. Except for the toiletries that really can't be squeezed out, the rest are very good. Free wifi, gym and ice making upstairs. There is no free bottled water in the room. Hygiene: The overall lobby and room are good, and they are cleaned very well. 😡But the worst housekeeping must hang a sign, I encountered it twice: The first time, the waitress knocked on the door and said housekeeping, but she didn't listen at all and didn't wait for a second. I didn't have time to say wait a minute. At that time, I didn't wear all my clothes. Fortunately, the room was big and I was inside. The second time, I was in the bathroom near the door, and a male waiter didn't knock on the door and just swiped the card and pushed the door in, with a huge bang. Fortunately, the bolt was stuck. I was very angry and opened the door to argue with him. He still said housekeeping with a nonchalant look, but he had just done cleaning in the morning, and he changed his words and said he was just checking. Later, I was very angry and said that you should at least knock on the door, and he reluctantly said sorry and left. After closing the door, I still heard him telling others that I yelled at him. In this case, you can call the police in the United States. Every time the housekeeping gave extra tips, and specially wrote a message to remind them that there was a time difference, and they had to deal with emails at night and sleep during the day, but they still didn't get any respect and personal space, and didn't respect the privacy of guests at all. Finally, the front desk was really good, patiently helped solve problems, and prepared everything in advance, which made me very grateful. It can be seen that the grade and level of the housekeeping department is far behind that of the front desk and bellman.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Response from Property: We are very sorry for any issue you faced during your stay. We will forward this to the proper department. We hope you enjoyed your stay.
Wodemingzijiaolaola
Executive Junior Suite
Stayed in Apr 2024
Family
51 review
5.0/5
Outstanding
Posted on Jun 26, 2024
Most hotels in Manhattan are old, and this one is no exception, but it is well maintained. The hotel is very busy every day, and you have to wait for several elevators during peak hours. The hotel is within walking distance of Central Park, Times Square, Moma, etc.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Response from Property: Thank you for choosing us as a part of your NewYork City experience, we hope you'll see us againduring your next stay.
Lulubushilulu
Penthouse
Stayed in Oct 2024
Business travellers
35 review
4.7/5
Amazing
Posted on Dec 7, 2024
The room is in a great location and is clean, but the heating is not good. However, the lighting is good so it doesn't feel cold. Overall, I am satisfied.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Response from Property: Thank you for choosing us as a part of your NewYork City experience, we hope you'll see us againduring your next stay.
Anonymous User
One Bedroom Suite
Stayed in Jun 2024
Family
2 review
4.7/5
Amazing
Posted on Jul 22, 2024
The room was very clean overall. There was no stale smell in the room. The air conditioner was cold enough, the window mat was very comfortable, and the sofa bed was also very comfortable. It was large enough after being opened, soft and comfortable, and very suitable for family and children. There was a small kitchen in the room and a glass round table that could seat 4-5 people, which was very convenient. There were two toilets that could be used at the same time. The only drawback was that the shower water was a little slow to drain, resulting in a little water accumulation when taking a shower.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Response from Property: Thank you for choosing us as a part of your NewYork City experience, we hope you'll see us againduring your next stay.
Guest User
Penthouse
Stayed in Apr 2024
Couples
7 review
0.5/5
Posted on May 11, 2024
The room was extremely noisy. Even the staff thought it was noisy, but they said no one had said anything was wrong. Why sell such a room? I booked two nights, but I didn't stay at all. The hotel didn't have any attitude of refund or negotiation. The hotel manager said there was nothing we could do about the noise, and asked us to be more polite. How could we be more polite? After flying for so long, we still had to listen to the noise at night. It was really bad. Ctrip's ability to handle problems was also very poor. In short, 0 points for the whole trip.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Guest User
Penthouse
Stayed in Jul 2024
Family
34 review
1.7/5
Posted on Sep 1, 2024
Hotels in the United States are really hard to describe!
Original TextTranslated by Google
Response from Property: Thank you for choosing us as a part of your NewYork City experience, we hope you'll see us againduring your next stay.
Anonymous User
One Bedroom Suite
Stayed in Jul 2023
Family
2 review
5.0/5
Outstanding
Posted on Sep 13, 2023
The room is large and spacious, with 2 bathrooms. The living room has a round table, microwave and refrigerator, suitable for traveling with children. The cleaning was also very clean. In addition, special thanks to the hotel for assisting in sending my husband's international driver's license that was left in the room back to us! Thanks!
Original TextTranslated by Google
Guest User
Executive Junior Suite
Stayed in Jan 2024
Family
4 review
4.0/5
Very Good
Posted on Feb 18, 2024
The location is good and the room facilities are acceptable. Although it is a bit old, in New York, it is very satisfying for the whole family to have a good sleep after a tiring day. We stayed for four nights. Special thanks to Adam, the front desk staff, who quickly solved the problem of the cold room and lack of bedding in our room, allowing us to have a good rest for the next three days. He deserves praise! There is also room service staff, Ms. Huang from Guangzhou, China, who helped us adjust the air conditioner and taught us how to put on bedding. She was very enthusiastic and considerate! Thank you all!
Original TextTranslated by Google
Anonymous User
Executive Junior Suite
Stayed in Jun 2023
Family
33 review
4.5/5
Great
Posted on Jul 9, 2023
Being old and young is a common problem in New York. This hotel is ok. Good location, easy to go everywhere, friendly staff. Midway between Central Park and Times Square.
Original TextTranslated by Google
Laohuang2
Executive Junior Suite
Stayed in Oct 2023
Family
7 review
4.0/5
Very Good
Posted on Nov 26, 2023
Stayed for 5 days. The room was large and the location was good. The breakfast was just mediocre. It turned out that there was breakfast when Ctrip made the reservation. When we checked in, we were told it wasn't available. We had to communicate with each other many times to make it up. They were also told that we couldn't eat it in the restaurant and had to take it back to the room to eat.
Original TextTranslated by Google