Not convinced this was right for us. So, you can’t fault the views and although Google Maps clearly prioritised saving 100 yards rather than any logical route, the location is good too, just go via Dunkeld or Blairgowrie and ignore any cross country alternative. We had a superior room so loads of space and a great view and I couldn’t fault the bed, furniture or bathroom, the lighting was a bit dull, like almost every hotel these days. The common parts are as in the photos, lots of wood, ancient pottery and pictures of random people from the last few centuries. There were real log fires burning and a stuffed bear as well as the obligatory antlers and polished brass all over the place. The food was good for rural Scotland, hardly cutting edge cuisine, but given the hotel’s traditional style that’s not surprising, it was strange being asked to order dinner well before hand, but I guess that helps planning and reduces waste. The menu choices were OK, but it isn’t a huge menu so some will be disappointed I’m sure. On the other hand, given the choices nearby the restaurant is clearly the most ‘upmarket’ choice for miles. It was, however, ‘quiet’ most of the time. However, here’s where we hit the ‘not so good’ bits. Firstly breakfast is quite late at 8:30, probably to allow the staff an 8am start, but not so good for guests wanting to be out and about early. Similarly dinner is in a relatively small time slot. There’s no room service (but we did get a pot of tea and some cake during the afternoon). In our room there was no tea or coffee making facility - bottled water was provided but if you wake up at 6am it’s a long wait until breakfast. I’d expect more at this price point. Service was excellent, the staff are first class, but the general atmosphere is between relaxed and moribund and for us the old fashioned feel, restricted timing, lack of in room tea / coffee facilities and room service made it an experience we won’t repeat. Your priorities might be very different.